Data source is Pat Shillingburg, E-mail pat@takus.com
The family is listed in the 1880, 1900 & 1910 census census living in Union, Grant Co., WV
In the 1910 census, Ellen is not living with William, but it says she is a widow. 4 of the children are living with her. William is listed as being single and living with the Kitzmiller sisters as a handyman.